
It must be tough to be a Toledo Rockets fan right now. Apparently gambling has become an issue on campus. Last year in football, this year in basketball.
Just to be clear, by “has become an issue” I mean that people have been caught doing it.
As long as there are sports there will be gambling on sports. As long as there is gambling on sports there will be people who try to get an inside edge by getting people to point shave. It is essentially as simple as that.
The reason why I’m sure it is far more prevalent in the NCAA is that at that stage of your life, you’re young, you aren’t making any money and you honestly don’t know if you’ll make it or not.
Look at all the people who play D1 college football and basketball, how many of them actually go pro? 2-5%?
Imagine being 20 and being talented enough to play D1 basketball, you go to a decent school, it isn’t Kansas or Illinois or Duke or anything, but it is a competitive program, and you are the second string point guard.
So you spent your whole life playing basketball, you were the best player in your neighborhood growing up, the best player at Boys and Girls club, the best player on your high school team so you get to a D1 program and you are maybe the 7th best player on the team.
Maybe you’ll make it. Probably you won’t.
You don’t have any cash flow because you spend all your time playing basketball, traveling, practicing and, when you aren’t doing all of the above you still have to go to classes.
And remember, you are 18 or 19 or 20 and in college. It’s college. You want to have fun.
Someone approaches you and says you can make an easy $2,000 by missing a couple free throws in one game. You say “why not?”, miss the shots, make some money. And from there they keep calling you and you get pulled in. You get paid to play for them. You sure as hell aren’t getting paid to play in college (not at Toledo anyway).

The next thing you know, you’re involved with “La Casa Nostra” (according to ESPN), you didn’t realize what you were doing was actually hurting anyone because the way you see it, you were probably going to miss some shots anyway and this might have been your only chance to get paid to play basketball.
And now you’re on trial for $250,000 or 5 years in prison? Really?
How much do you think Sammy Villegas even made by complying with these requests? Maybe $5,000. Maybe $10,000. Maybe $20,000? There’s no way for us to know. But the reason why I bring it up is, I sincerely doubt there is ANY way he made a quarter of a million dollars. Maybe he did. But if he didn’t, the punishment really doesn’t fit the crime.
I agree that point shaving is wrong.
I just don’t think we should rush to crucify the participants.
The system is flawed. If these kids were getting paid to play college sports we would hear far less about all the payment scandals and point shaving. And you can make the “Well they are getting an education worth $200,000″ argument all day long, but the bottom line is, most of the top tier kids who participate in D1 sports aren’t going on to Med School or Law School or Grad School or Business School.
Most of them own their campus, show up for class only when they feel like it and major in general studies. Look at the NBA draft this year, how many Freshmen were drafted? 18? That one year of ‘college’ isn’t exactly going to take them very far.
These top tier players are not being prepared for the real world by programs that don’t hold them academically accountable, so why pretend that the education is worth ANYTHING?
The system is flawed and until the NCAA decides to stop pretending that it isn’t, there will be point shaving scandals, payment scandals, academic scandals…etc.
Yes, the idea of college sports is great.
The execution is embarrassing.