Here is my defense against a sad Detroiter who thinks it is lunacy to trade ManRam:
That’s the thing about sports—you want to win. The Red Sox are basically in first place in the AL East, they should absolutely make the playoffs. In the baseball playoffs, anything can happen. Detroit backed into the 2006 playoffs, basically carrying the dead carcass of a great early season team. And then we destroyed the Yankees and rumbled into the World Series.
Who are you scared of? The Rays are interesting but greener than Al Gore. I’ve been asked to join the Yankees’ starting rotation. Anaheim is probably the favorite, and they score less than Michael Richards at bars in Compton.
I’ve long been a proponent of tearing up the Pistons’ foundation. But success in the NBA is so much about massaging the salary cap and in basketball the better team almost always wins (and the Pistons have proven they’re not an elite team.) The Red Sox, on the other hand, won the World Series LAST YEAR.
If you can get a great package for an aging superstar, an aging top 20 of all-time player, you might take a look. But you’re the damn defending world champions and you’ve got at least a 1 in 5 shot of making the World Series. To pass that up would be crazier than Manny Ramirez.
Disagree. This team isn’t winning shit. You know that, or should know that, and I know that. They are HORRIBLE HORRIBLE HORRIBLE HORRIBLE under pressure.
THIS TEAM HAS BEEN SWEPT 6 TIMES SLOAN! 6 TIMES!!!
Let’s take a look at how they have performed against quality opponents this season:
Against the LA Angels (whom I predict will take it all): 1-5
Against the New York Yankees (who are having troubles of their own): 5-6
Against the Tampa Bay Rays: 6-6 (2 sweeps for each team, the home team)
Against the A’s (not a playoff team): 3-4
This Red Sox team has consistently beat up on the likes of the O’s, Blue Jays, Royals…etc. But they don’t win on the road and they don’t play well under pressure. They just don’t hold leads.
THEY ARE 24-32 ON THE ROAD. THAT IS AN EIGHT GAME DIFFERENCE. Let me list for you other teams that have lost 8 or more games on the road than they have won on the road:
Baltimore (last place…12)
Cleveland (last place…16)
Seattle (last place…14)
Atlanta (fourth place…17)
Washington (last place…19)
Cincinnati (third place…11)
Pittsburgh (last place…14)
Colorado (third place…19)
San Diego (last place…17)
These are the 9 teams the Red Sox have a better road record than. That’s it. HORRIBLE.
Right now, the Red Sox are 31-13 at home. That’s great. But I doubt they win another 30 of their remaining 37 games at home. They are not going to go 61-20 at home. And if they somehow do and continue at this rate on the road, they’ll end up winning about 91 games and missing the playoffs or sneaking in as a Wild Card.
I know Red Sox teams. I’ve been watching them forever. This one doesn’t stand a chance.
They’re like the late 90’s Red Sox. Look fine. Get you a little excited, get into the playoffs, give up a shit load of runs, no one can hit. Swept away.
It would also be stupid NOT TO TRADE Manny. he actually wants to leave, he won’t re-sign. Theo isn’t going to pick up the option (which I think they should, but won’t) so why not trade him, reallocate some of his salary for pitching next season and get a nice package in return? I’m not saying that the money being spent on Manny is preventing anything from happening, but once it is not being used anymore I’m sure the ownership will be a lot more likely to go out and spend a little money on free agents this Winter. Plus, if they can trade Manny for prospects, maybe they can work those prospects into a deal for someone this off season.
It If they don’t trade him, he walks, the Red Sox get eliminated in the ALCS (Best case…probably in the DS) and they get NOTHING in return.
I don’t give a shit about his salary. I’m just saying, its stupid not to make a move here.
I also don’t understand the need for the “WE MUST WIN THIS SEASON” mentality.
The Red Sox won the World Series last year. They aren’t going to repeat with this team. I give them a 1 in 19 chance at best. Maybe 1 in 15. No better than that. Not enough pitching. Not enough clutch.
I would be thrilled if they did win the World Series, of course, but I don’t think they have a legitimate chance with this particular group of players performing the way they have this season and I also think it would make much more sense to build to be in a better position next year than to let Manny leave for nothing (which he will) and to end up being in a worse position next year.
Also, if they DO trade with the Mets or Dodgers (both more likely than other teams, due to market, payroll, playoff race…etc.) and get a package with like Ryan Church a solid bullpen arm and some minor leaguers, its not like they would fall off the face of the Earth with Chruch as a starter and an extra arm in the pen.
If anything I think they might even IMPROVE their chances for THIS YEAR if they can move Manny for an arm or two and a nice outfielder who can provide them with a .285 or so BA. Just saying.
Shit, I would GLADLY take Matt Kemp, an arm and some prospects for Manny. Someone young, who can hit, steal bases, plays hard, and still leaves the door open for a big free agent signing. I really don’t think this Red Sox team becomes irrelevant the second after Manny is gone. But why not try it now? Try it with a trade. See how it works out for the remainder of the season.
If they sink, they know they need to make a big signing in the off season. If they swim, maybe not so much.